As an expert in the field, I would lean towards suggesting that using BERT for motion capture (mocap) data might not be the most efficient or straightforward approach, especially when compared to using an LSTM. However, whether it’s a “waste of time” depends on various factors, including your specific objectives, the nature of your mocap data, and your willingness to engage in potentially extensive model adaptation and experimentation. Here’s a more detailed breakdown:
-
Natural Fit for Sequential Data: LSTMs are inherently suited for sequential data like mocap, which involves time series of movements or poses.
-
Capturing Temporal Dynamics: LSTMs excel in capturing temporal dependencies and can effectively model the progression and patterns in mocap data.
-
Established Precedent: There is a substantial amount of research and precedent for using LSTMs in time-series and sequential data applications, including motion capture.
-
Model Purpose and Design: BERT is primarily designed for natural language processing and understanding. Adapting it for mocap data, which is fundamentally different from text data, can be challenging and might require significant modification.
-
Pretraining Relevance: BERT’s pretraining on language data might not offer much benefit for mocap data, and retraining or fine-tuning such a complex model on a completely different type of data can be resource-intensive.
-
Lack of Precedent: There’s limited precedent for using BERT with mocap data, which means you might face uncharted challenges and a lack of established best practices.
-
Research and Innovation: If your goal is to explore new methods and push the boundaries of what’s possible with mocap data, experimenting with BERT could be insightful, albeit time-consuming and challenging.
-
Practical Application and Efficiency: If you are looking for the most efficient and proven approach for processing mocap data, an LSTM is likely a better choice.
-
Resource Availability: Consider the resources (time, computational power, expertise) you have at your disposal. BERT is a more complex and resource-intensive model compared to LSTMs.
While experimenting with BERT on mocap data could be interesting from a research perspective, it is not the most practical or efficient approach given the current state of technology and understanding in the field. For most practical applications involving motion capture data, an LSTM is likely to be more effective and less resource-intensive. However, the final decision should be based on your specific project goals, resources, and willingness to venture into less explored territories of model application.